Homemade Nutella Marshmallow Cookies

The pot lid rattles and you know dinner is almost ready. That familiar sound gets you excited, but today, your mind’s on the dessert waiting just a little later. You recall opening the Nutella jar, thinking how perfect it’d be for a special cookie treat. The smell of toasted marshmallow kinda lingers as you gather the ingredients.

You spot the mixing bowls and measuring cups needing to get busy next. The float valve pops up on your pressure cooker, reminding you that the tender pull on the cookies’ texture is about to hit just right. You wanna get those gooey marshmallows ready while the cookies bake in the oven, so timing’s gotta be sharp.

Then you notice how the sugar blends with the Nutella and egg like a charm. As the mixture turns smooth, you think about the quick release on the timer, which keeps things from overcooking. No stresses, just perfect cookies soon ready to sandwich with that toasted marshmallow. You feel the valve hiss when it’s time to open the cooker and check if the tender pull is just set.

The Truth About Fast Tender Results

• Pressure build happens fast in your cooker, so baking cookies feels quicker than usual.
• The float valve popping up signals the perfect moment to use quick release for that tender, gooey bite.
• High heat lets your marshmallows toast just right without burning the Nutella spread inside the sandwiches.
• Covering cookies right after baking traps moisture making them soft with that tender pull you love.
• Using your pressure cooker alongside the oven for this recipe keeps things speedy but still oh-so-delicious.

Everything You Need Lined Up

Gather these ingredients before you get started. It makes everything smoother that way. You’ll need 3 quarters cup Nutella, which is the star player here. The sweet and nutty flavor makes the whole cookie shine, trust me.

Next, grab 3 quarters cup sugar for some sweetness and one egg to hold it all together. Vanilla extract is a must for that cozy flavor, so measure one teaspoon. The flour, just 3 quarters cup, gives the cookies their tender structure without heaviness.

Don’t forget 3 large egg whites too. They whip up into soft peaks and get folded in for a light texture. Add half a cup sugar and another teaspoon vanilla extract to the egg whites. This combo makes the outer cookies fluffier and tender.

How It All Comes Together Step by Step

Step one is preheating your oven to 350°F. Make sure it’s ready when you are. Then, mix Nutella, sugar, egg, and vanilla in a medium bowl. You want it smooth, no lumps in sight.

Step two, slowly add the flour to the mix. Stir just enough to combine it all. Over mixing can make the cookies tough, so take it easy. In step three, whip those 3 egg whites separately until they hold soft peaks. It’s a bit of patience but worth it.

Step four, gently fold the whipped whites into your Nutella dough. This is key for a tender pull, so be careful not to deflate the mix.

Step five, drop spoonfuls of dough on a lined baking tray, spacing them 2 inches apart. They need room to bake evenly.

Bake for 10 to 12 minutes or until the edges set. When the timer signals, use quick release from the oven and let them cool for a few. Step six is the fun part. Spread Nutella on the bottom of half your cookies, then sandwich with another cookie.

Last, grab those filled cookies and toast them over an open flame or broiler. This makes your marshmallow toast lightly, adding that golden, slightly crispy finish you’ll love. Watch the float valve as you toast so you don’t burn it. Enjoy!

Time Savers That Actually Work

• Set your oven to preheat before mixing, so it’s ready when cookies hit the tray.
• Use the mixer for whipping egg whites fast instead of doing it by hand.
• Line baking sheets in advance. It saves seconds but adds up big when baking batches.
• While cookies bake, get out your Nutella and spreader ready so sandwiching happens quicker.
• Toast marshmallows over gas burner flame or broiler while others cool, multitasking like a pro.

That First Bite Moment

The first bite’s soft yet has a little tender pull hint that gets you every time. The Nutella oozes slightly, mixing with the warm marshmallow’s toasted edges. It’s kinda sticky but in the best way, pulling apart slowly.

You notice the toasted marshmallow flavor that’s sweet and smoky, making each bite feel like a cozy campfire treat. The cookie part crumbles just right while the marshmallow stays soft and rich. You can’t help but smile.

This warm, gooey yumminess pairs perfectly with a cold glass of milk or your favorite coffee. You savor how the textures and flavors dance together in perfect harmony. These cookies aren’t just desserts, they’re little happy moments.

Smart Storage That Actually Works

Storing these cookies, you wanna keep the toasted marshmallow soft but not too sticky. Keep them in an airtight container at room temperature for up to three days. They stay just right, not dried out or too gooey.

If you gotta save for longer, pop them in the fridge wrapped in wax paper, then into a sealed container. This adds a couple more days of freshness but might firm the marshmallow up some.

For serious saving, freeze the cookies sandwiched but before toasting. Wrap them tightly in plastic wrap and place in a freezer bag. When ready, thaw and toast just like fresh for that tender pull return.

Always separate layers with parchment paper to keep them from sticking together. When you toast before eating, they freshen up real good and make you feel like you just baked them.

Your Most Asked Questions Answered

Can I use a different nut butter instead of Nutella? You sure can. Peanut butter or almond butter works okay, but Nutella gives that unique chocolate-hazelnut vibe. Check out our Creamy Garlic Shrimp and Rice Skillet for more rich-flavored recipes.

What if I don’t have a pressure cooker? No worries. This recipe mainly uses the oven, but a pressure cooker helps speed up prep and keep moist cookie texture with tender pull. For quicker meals, try our Creamy Steak Pasta – Ready in 30 Minutes.

Why fold whipped egg whites? Folding keeps the air in the mix, making cookies light and tender, with that kinda soft, lovely texture.

Can I skip the toasted marshmallow step? You can, but the toasting adds a smoky, warm charm that makes these cookies special and gooey.

How do I know when to quick release? Watch the float valve in your pressure cooker. When it pops and shows pressure build, you gotta release quickly so the cookies don’t dry out.

What’s the best way to toast marshmallows for this recipe? Use a gas burner or broiler for quick, even toasting. Keep an eye for the first golden spots, then pull away so it doesn’t burn.